The Helen Suzman Foundation has gone to court to challenge Home Affairs Minister Aaron Motsoaledi`s decision to terminate the Zimbabwean Exemption Permit.
The permit allows around 178 000 Zimbabwean nationals to live and work in South Africa.
Arguments were based on whether the decision was administrative or executive and if it was procedurally unfair and irrational.
Was the decision not to renew the Zimbabwean Exemption Permit (ZEP) an administrative or executive action or was it irrational, antithetical to the Constitution and procedurally unfair?

These are some of the questions that a full bench of the Gauteng High Court in Pretoria will seek to answer before delivering judgment in a case relating to the effective termination of the ZEP.

The Helen Suzman Foundation (HSF) is challenging the decision of Home Affairs Minister Aaron Motsoaledi after he announced in December 2021 that the ZEP would not be renewed.

During the economic and political strife in Zimbabwe in 2008 and 2009, many of the country`s citizens fled to South Africa.

At the time, the South African government decided to create a blanket exemption so that Zimbabweans could get permits to live and work in the country legally.

The permits were effectively extended by creating another permit over the years, which has since become known as the ZEP. More than 178 000 ZEP holders have been in South Africa for more than a decade.

Policy decision

During the two-day hearing, the court heard that Motsoaledi had not terminated the ZEP but that the programme had expired by effluxion of time.

The minister decided not to renew or create another permit for ZEP holders, as had been done in the years before. The minister also extended the validity of the ZEPs to help holders organise their affairs.

Advocate Ismail Jamie, SC, for the minister and director-general of home affairs, said ZEP holders were given until June 2023 to regularise their stay in South Africa by applying for other visas or asking to be exempt from the expiration of the ZEP through a waiver.

Jamie based a large part of his argument on it being a policy decision.

He explained that giving a blanket exemption to Zimbabwean nationals entering South Africa in the 2000s was a policy decision based on the issues in the neighbouring country at the time.

Similarly, the decision not to create a further exemption was also policy, which he said was based on rational reasons, which included budgetary constraints, improvements in the conditions in Zimbabwe and a backlog in the asylum system.

He said such a policy decision was not up for judicial scrutiny and that only the policy`s implementation could be challenged in a court of law. However, he conceded that the decision

still had to be rational and could not be antithetical to the Constitution.

He explained that giving a blanket exemption to Zimbabwean nationals entering South Africa in the 2000s was a policy decision based on the issues in the neighbouring country at the time.

Similarly, the decision not to create a further exemption was also policy, which he said was based on rational reasons, which included budgetary constraints, improvements in the conditions in Zimbabwe and a backlog in the asylum system.

He said such a policy decision was not up for judicial scrutiny and that only the policy`s implementation could be challenged in a court of law. However, he conceded that the decision still had to be rational and could not be antithetical to the Constitution.

Budlender said on the respondent`s version the principle of legality had been violated. This was because Motsoaledi said his decision was final and would not be reconsidered and that the call for representations was not made before the decision. And when the call was made, it did not relate to the decision to end the blanket exemption, Budlender added.

Budlender also maintained that the minister did not consider the impact of the decision on ZEP holders and their children.

`The inevitable effect of the minister`s decision is that, on 30 June 2023, tens of thousands of ZEP holders will be left undocumented. This is due to the legal and practical barriers to securing alternative visas and permits,` Budlender said.

While Ismail argued that it was considered, Budlender pointed out that there was no affidavit from the minister and, as such, no evidence of that consideration.

The All Truck Drivers` Forum and Allied South Africa, another party to the proceedings, argued that the minister was not empowered to extend the permit programme in the first place.

Advocate David Mtsweni, for the truckers, also raised arguments that no exceptional circumstances existed which allowed the creation of the exemption regime in the first place. Mtsweni said the blanket exemption programme was only meant for foreign nationals who were in the country lawfully, which was not the case for ZEP holders.

HSF wants a declaration of invalidity and for Motsoaledi`s decision to be set aside. It also wants a temporary order directing that, pending the conclusion of a fair process, existing ZEPs should be deemed valid, and that ZEP holders should continue to enjoy the protections afforded by Immigration Directive 1 of 2021 and Directive 2 of 2022.

Judgment has been reserved. V.4792

I recently renewed my passport at Home Affairs in a bank branch and was very impressed with the service and quick turnaround time. The Department of Home Affairs (DHA) and major banks first launched the option to do Smart ID card and passport applications via select bank branches in 2016. It has slowly grown to around 30 locations, including branches from Absa, Discovery Bank, FNB, Investec, Nedbank, and Standard Bank. My passport was set to expire in October 2024, and because many countries require that your passport be valid for six months from a travel date, a renewal was due. V.5324
Click here for full article

DA MP says this is up 20 000 from the 74 000 six months previously Department of Home Affairs visa backlog is up by 20 000 in 6 months The Democratic Alliance (DA) can reveal that the Department of Home Affairs (DHA) Visa backlog has increased from 74 000 in August 2023 to 92 000 as of 16 February 2024. This is an increase of just under 20 000 in about 6 months. Download the Parliamentary question and answer here. The increase goes against what the Minister told the Home Affairs Parliamentary Committee in March 2023. V.5325
Click here for full article

The European Union (EU) will limit visas for people from Ethiopia. This is because the Ethiopian government hasn`t been helping take back citizens who stay in the EU illegally. The EU Council announced this in a statement on Monday. Ethiopians won`t get visas for multiple entries anymore. Also, Ethiopians with diplomatic and service passports won`t have their visa fees waived. V.5326
Click here for full article

CRIMINAL convictions more than two decades ago came to haunt a man who was offered a job as a senior data discovery and enrichment expert, but after his prospective employer got wind of the convictions, retracted the job offer. But the Gqeberha Labour Court came to his rescue and found that the man should be given a second chance, given that his convictions occurred 20 years ago and had meanwhile been expunged. V.5327
Click here for full article

Nigeria’s economy, which ranked as Africa’s largest in 2022, is set to slip to fourth place this year and Egypt, which held the top position in 2023, is projected to fall to second behind South Africa after a series of currency devaluations, International Monetary Fund forecasts show. The IMF’s World Economic Outlook estimates Nigeria’s gross domestic product at $253 billion based on current prices this year, lagging energy-rich Algeria at $267 billion, Egypt at $348 billion and South Africa at $373 billion. V.5328
Click here for full article

There are fears that more people will be separated by the introduction of a minimum salary level for those wanting UK family visas. Families living in the UK and abroad have raised concerns about what new rules will mean for them as they try to reunite with foreign spouses. In December, the Home Office, which says migration to the UK is too high, announced a package of measures to reduce net migration, following a spike in arrival numbers. V.5318
Click here for full article

An Ethiopian asylum seeker, who does not speak English, claims he was duped by a senior immigration official into paying an admission of guilt fine when he thought he was paying for bail.Two Western Cape High Court judges have condemned the official`s `deplorable` behaviour, set aside the fine, and ordered the immigration official be taken off the case. Tsegaye Esyas claims Annelise van Dyk treated him like an animal which led to him attempt suicide while in police cells. V.5320
Click here for full article

EREMY MAGGS: I want to stay with crime now. Individuals with a criminal record may be faced with significant challenges when seeking employment, I think that’s a given. Here in South Africa, employers may legally exclude an applicant from consideration for a position if having a clean criminal record is what is termed an inherent requirement of the job. That phrase, inherent requirement, is important, but what exactly does that mean, and when can an applicant be lawfully excluded for having a criminal record? V.5321
Click here for full article

As a South African who has adopted a nomadic work lifestyle alongside my wife, Ingrid Lotze, I’ve been an interested observer of South Africa’s snail-pace digital nomad visa (DNV) development process. Despite the optimism surrounding its introduction, the visa seems to miss several crucial marks for digital nomads like us. V.5322
Click here for full article

DA MP says hours lost continue to result in persons being unable to collect their ID documents due to unmanageable queues The DA has been inundated with complaints that the Department of Home Affairs (DHA) systems are offline, resulting in long queues and delayed processing of documents. Through questions posed to the Minister, the DA can now reveal that the DHA has lost over 77 years’ worth of working hours due to system downtime and load-shedding from 2019 to date. Concerningly, this data only relates to hours lost for the application of smart IDs, meaning decades more of working hours could have been additionally lost in other spheres such as passport or visa applications. V.5314
Click here for full article