28-03-2024 13:00:49 (GMT +02:00) Pretoria / Cape Town, South Africa

Relief for over 700,000 citizens as high court declares ID blocking by Home Affairs unconstitutional
18. Jan. 2024 Daily Maverick

The Gauteng High Court handed down a landmark judgement on Tuesday, 16 January, declaring the Department of Home Affairs’ practice of blocking IDs unjust and inconsistent with the South African constitution. (Photo: Deaan Viviers / Gallo Images / Foto24)
The Department of Home Affairs is no longer allowed to block South African IDs arbitrarily, cutting citizens and residents off from essential services, following a landmark judgment from the Gauteng high court. Lawyers for Human Rights has welcome the ruling.
In a landmark judgment that has been years in the making, the Gauteng high court in Pretoria has declared that the Department of Home Affairs’ (DHA) practice of blocking South African IDs is an unjust and irregular administrative action that is inconsistent with the South African Constitution.
This comes after Minister Aaron Motsoaledi and Directer-General Livhuwani Makhode were taken to task by affected permanent resident and Civil Society organisations Lawyers For Human Rights, Legal Wise South Africa and the Children’s Institute, after the department went on a widespread campaign to block IDs it deemed suspicious and fraudulent.
The application was initially brought forward by Eswatini citizen Phindile Mazibuko, who has lived in South Africa since 1998 but had her ID blocked by Home Affairs and was under threat of having her permanent residency revoked. Lawyers for Human Rights (LHR) and Legal Wise South Africa applied to be joined as an applicant in the matter as a matter of public interest and to have their client’s IDs unblocked, while the Children’s Institute was admitted as a friend of the court.
The applicants argued that the practice of blocking IDs was unconstitutional because it left the affected parties in a state of statelessness. Perhaps perfectly summed up in LHR’s founding affidavit, the organisation argued that the blocking of IDs effectively prevents those affected from engaging with the world.
The civil society organisation argued, “They become ghosts in the system they cannot obtain passports and travel, they cannot access education and healthcare, they cannot open or access bank accounts.”
The consequences of the practice extend far beyond the affected adults, hindering the quality of life of children whose parents had their IDs blocked.
DHA ID blocking campaign
The issue dates back to May 2012 when DHA went on a drive to address the issue of duplicate IDs on the National Population Register. What started out as 29,000 identity documents having markers placed against them quickly escalated to over 1 million by 2020.
At the time when the application was heard, DHA had unblocked 1.8 million IDs. However, over 700,000 remained blocked.
The department framed the practice as an administrative tool that was necessary to maintain the accuracy and integrity of the National Population Register and combat suspected fraud and manipulation.
However, Lawyers for Human Rights condemned the practice, claiming that ID blocking had become increasingly arbitrary, with criteria that seemed subjective and discriminatory. DHA’s reasons for blocking identity documents included the shape of inoculation marks, records of frequent cross-border travel, alleged deportation records, inability to speak a specific local language,



 

bearing a foreign-sounding name or having a parent or spouse of foreign decent.
Another point of contention was that the DHA did not follow fair administrative processes before blocking IDs. Many of the IDs had markers placed against them which resulted in the documents being blocked without prior notice to the affected individuals depriving them of the opportunity to plead their case and provide information before being blocked by the DHA.
Blocking IDs declared unconstitutional
In passing down the judgement, High Court Judge Elmarie van der Schyff said that the Director General had a responsibility to protect the integrity of the national population register by “placing a marker” against any suspicious ID. However, Judge van der Schyff added that doing so without following just administrative procedure was mischief.
Judge Van der Schyff said that a mere suspicion that an ID document was fraudulent did not justify placing a marker on it and blocking an ID unless it is authorised through a court order, adding that the DHA jumped the gun.
In an answering affidavit, the DHA conceded that the IDs were blocked without a fair and just administrative process, admitting that it was inconsistent with the Constitution. It informed the court that it had developed a procedurally fair and transparent system that has since been implemented. However, the system still entails the placing of markers or blocking of IDs.
DHA has been ordered to determine whether unblocking the ID documents currently blocked will constitute a security risk and determine the status of Lawyers for Human Rights and Legal Wise clients within 90 days. The declaration has been suspended for 12 months, giving the DHA time to comply with the order.
‘A first step’ says Lawyers for Human Rights
Touching on the Constitutional Court’s emphases that the systematic act of stripping millions of black South Africans of their citizenship was one of the most pernicious policies of the apartheid regime, which left many as foreigners in the land of [their] birth, Lawyers for Human Rights welcomed the ruling.
Speaking to Daily Maverick, LHR’s Legal Consultant for Statelessness, Palesa Maloisane, said: “LHR is happy that the court has agreed to order the DHA to ensure a just and fair process that is in line with the Constitution and the Promotion of Administrative Justice Act, particularly because ID blocking can result in statelessness as it effectively strips affected individuals of their citizenship and dignity.”
Maloisane added that the organisation hoped that the judgment would be seriously considered by the department and inform the swift resolution to LHR’s client’s cases, particularly when children are involved.
“The case is a great success and first step in enabling all those affected to begin getting their lives and dignity as citizens back. Many clients have waited patiently for a resolution and will hopefully have the opportunity to access services that are crucial to citizenship and part of their daily lives,” Maloisane said. V.5170

More related News

 
Home Affairs blocked from deporting ‘critical skills’ Czech executive
26. Mar. 2025 Moneyweb
  Students in limbo as higher education dept deregisters Damelin, Lyceum College and CityVarsity
26. Mar. 2025 News24

Dzmitry Dzenisiuk was deployed to SA in 2014, with his wife joining him under a spousal visa. Both applied for visa extensions in February 2021. Image: Moneyweb The Department of Home Affairs (DHA) has been blocked by the Pretoria High Court from deporting a foreign worker and his wife, both of whom had been refused visa extensions, based on its failure to properly consider the documents supplied in their visa applications. This is the latest in a string of court losses notched up by Home Affairs. In the latest ruling, the high court ruled that the decision not to renew the visa of two foreign nationals must be set aside and returned to Home Affairs for reconsideration. V.5260
Click here for full article


 

Damelin, CityVarsity, Icesa City Campus and Lyceum College are reportedly being shut down after failing to submit their financial statements for 2021 and 2022. • The department of higher education has cancelled the registrations of Damelin, CityVarsity, Icesa City Campus and Lyceum College. • The announcement was made in the Government Gazette on Friday. • The department`s action follows the failure by the owner of the colleges, Educor, to submit audited financial statements for the 2021 and 2022 annual reports. The fate of hundreds of thousands of students registered with Damelin, CityVarsity, Icesa City Campus and Lyceum College hang in the balance after the institutions` registrations were cancelled by the department of higher education. V.5261
Click here for full article


SA government tackles companies hiring undocumented foreigners
28. Mar. 2024 SA people News
  Govt to crack down on unaccompanied children entering SA through borders
28. Mar. 2024 EWN

Employment and Labour Minister, Thulas Nxesi has warned South African companies against hiring undocumented foreigners. Minister Thulas Nxesi of Employment and Labour (DEL) has strongly warned South African companies against hiring undocumented foreigners. THINGS TOUGHEN UP FOR UNDOCUMENTED FOREIGNERS DEL has given a stern warning to all South African companies should they employ foreigners who are undocumented they shall be fined. This comes after a Zimbabwean nation Kudakwashe Mpofu, who was working as the Chief Financial Officer (CFO) in the North West Development Cooperation while illegally in the country, appeared in the Pretoria Magistrate’s Court on Wednesday. According to IOL Nxesi’s statement follows Home Affairs Minister Aaron Motsoaledi’s call for stricter penalties on employers who knowingly employ undocumented foreigners, just a month ago. V.5263
Click here for full article


 

The Border Management Authority wants Zimbabwean children entering South Africa by themselves to carry their passports. A South African National Defence Force (SANDF) soldier walks along the border fence that separates South Africa and Zimbabwe, near the Beitbridge border post, near Musina, on January 8, 2021. Picture: Guillem Sartorio/AFP JOHANNESBURG - The Department of Social Development and the Border Management Authority (BMA) say they will crack down on the influx of unaccompanied children entering the country through the Beitbridge and Grobler`s Bridge borders. This follows a meeting with Zimbabwean authorities who discussed how operations would be intensified to put a stop to the practice during the Easter long weekend. Border management said Zimbabwean children entering South Africa by themselves must carry their passports. V.5264
Click here for full article


Scores of undocumented foreigners deported after daring escape
28. Mar. 2024 IOL
  Questions over Home Affairs’ high customer satisfaction statistics
28. Mar. 2024 The Mercury

The department of Home Affairs has deported thousands of undocumented foreign nationals after a daring escape that took place at the Lindela Repatriation Centre in Krugersdorp last week. The department confirmed last week that it would also be investigating an escape of 69 undocumented foreigners, and look into a nearly R60 million contract it pays annually to the security company that was on duty when the escape took place. V.5265
Click here for full article


 

Home Affairs Minister Aaron Motsoaledi outlined the customer satisfaction statistics in his response to a recent parliamentary question from Cope president Mosiuoa Lekota regarding the progress made in resolving the myriad issues faced by clients. While a 2022/2023 Home Affairs survey showed generally high satisfaction scores from clients for the service they received at the department’s offices, opposition parties have said the statistics are misleading. Home Affairs Minister Aaron Motsoaledi outlined the customer satisfaction statistics in his response to a recent parliamentary question from Cope president Mosiuoa Lekota regarding the progress made in resolving the myriad issues faced by clients. “Customer satisfaction score for each service channel was generally high with scores above 70%. However, harbours and airports had the highest satisfaction score of over 90% whereas refugee centres had the lowest score of 73%,” the minister said. V.5266
Click here for full article


Immigrants not to blame for high crime, graft in SA, state witness
25. Mar. 2024 Sunday World
  South Africans love Home Affairs for its effectiveness, says Motsoaledi
25. Mar. 2024 Businesstech

The high levels of crime, unemployment, and poor public healthcare in South Africa are not caused by immigrants, but by the government’s poor governance and corruption. The blaming and scapegoating of immigrants for South Africa’s socio-economic problems arises primarily because of the failure of government policy. Also blamed is implementation, mismanagement, and corruption. This in all the education, health, and housing provisions. V.5253
Click here for full article


 

Home Affairs Minister says his department is “generally praised for its effectiveness”, and the data collected by the department is evidence of this. In a recent parliamentary Q&A, the Minister of Home Affairs, Aaron Motsoaledi, was asked whether his department had solved the problem of long queues and denial of service on reaching the counter after a long time in the queue. The question also included an inquiry into his findings on citizen satisfaction with the service provided by his department. In response, Motsoaledi said customer satisfaction and waiting times are constantly monitored across all DHA branches and noted the average waiting time inside an office is reasonably quick, albeit with some caveats. V.5257
Click here for full article


New immigration laws for South Africa coming, five years too late
25. Mar. 2024 Businesstec
  Spain’s digital nomad visa one year on: How are remote workers and locals getting along?
25. Mar. 2024 Euronews

The Department of Home Affairs plans to introduce new amendments to South Africa’s immigration laws missing a Constitutional Court deadline by five years. In 2017, Lawyers for Human Rights took the Minister of Home Affairs and others to court over the treatment of detained foreign nationals. The Constitutional Court ruled that sections 34(1)(b) and (d) of the Immigration Act of 2002 were invalid and unconstitutional. V.5258
Click here for full article


 

Spain introduced its digital nomad visa last year. Here`s how it`s going so far. A year after Spain launched a special digital nomad visa to encourage foreign business talent to move to the country, it has met with muted success. Some 300 foreign nationals were granted the visa up until 31 December 2023, the Spanish Foreign Ministry said, but it did not disclose their nationalities. The relatively small number may relate to the problems encountered by some applicants keen to make a new life under the Iberian sun. Some said it was hard to fulfil all the visa’s demands like proving they pay social security in their own country. Others complained of the endless paperwork involved in the process. Euronews Travel spoke to visa experts, applicants and locals to find out more. How easy is it to get a digital nomad visa in Spain? V.5259
Click here for full article



Search
South Africa Immigration Company